The Survivalist Challenges will test Arthur's ability to survive in the wild by catching fish, hunting animals, and more. *. Horseman 10 is a pain but I found a wild Hungarian Halfbred spawned next to Emerald Ranch. Kill 3 flying birds. I'm really lost, and I'm unable to get the last 2 challenges for the legend of the east outfit. Bandit Challenges are gameplay challenges which involve robberies, horse and stagecoach thefts and other malicious acts in the single-player of Red Dead Redemption 2. Click "show more" for time stamps, links and discussion:Individual plants can be found at these points in the video:0:07 Milkweed (1/15)0:48 Common Bulrush (. Herbalist 9 Bugged (Acuna Orchid), Potentially 100% Breaking. 6 of them for 1 Tonic. Our text guide to all the. In this guide, you will find how to complete the herbalist challenge #10 in Red Dead Redemption 2. - $5, Dead Eye EXP. Weapons Expert. If you run into that issue you can fix if by going to where the legendary blue gill is and catching three regular blue gills there. Healing. At least I’m rdr2 they reduced the amount like the rock carvings to find, but these challenges to me aren’t fun. To unlock the next, you need to complete the first one, you cannot simultaneously perform two challenges of the same kind. After you have the 38 out of 43 herbs picked, replay the mission “Who is Not Without Sin”, and play until you have gotten Gambler 10 done. Reward: New holster. Single-player Challenges are tasks that the player can complete in the single-player mode of Red Dead Redemption 2 in order to earn rewards. The type of grinds where you have to wait for the plants to re-spawn. They are Bandit, Explorer, Gambler, Herbalist, Horseman, Master Hunter, Sharpshooter, Survivalist, and Weapons Expert. Those two were horrible for me. Herbalist 7: Craft and use 5 special miracle tonics. Herbalist - collect a yarrow. Gambler 2: 3 wins instead of 5 wins. Rank 3: Track 10 different animal species using your binoculars. The challenge category indicates the field of expertise players need to show to excel in. It is possible to complete this challenge thread as Arthur. Explorer Challenges are gameplay challenges which involve finding treasures in the single-player of Red Dead Redemption 2. . Its reward is 150 Health XP and $20. Bang boom. A mod that aims to make certain challenges easier and some harder. You check the challenge progress in game by clicking on D-pad left once> then go to 'Challenges' and select 'Herbalist 9’. Especially interested if anyone used mods for the herbalist challenge cuz for some reason it added the remaining plants that i. Can anyone tell me if it's possible to create a mod that unlocks the LoE outfit for Arthur. Challenge #2: Pick and Eat 4 Species of Berry. Good luck! I did the 100% on my last play through, but this is my first time trying to get all of the challenges done as Arthur. Red Dead Redemption 2 is a 2018 action-adventure game developed and published by Rockstar Games. They must be unlocked and completed in the. Herbalist Challenge 9 - All Plant. You check the challenge progress in game by clicking on D-pad left once> then go to 'Challenges' and select 'Herbalist 9’. Posted November 29, 2018. The problem with Herbalist 9, at least, is that the Compendium tracks everything you've ever found or studied or whatever. It explains what exactly the game requires to pass each of the challenges, and various solutions are offered. . After that I picked up all plants and Orchids with John (and got 15 Lady Slipper Orchids) for the exotic mission buut I found out it is not counted towards the challenge until you completing the first exotic mission. How to get the New Austin herbs and complete Herbalist 9 as Arthur Morgan as early as Chapter 2 using Eden's buggy method. Tip, Save any Indian tobacco you have for the next challenge. a pop-up shows up telling you that you've started the herbalist challenge. Purchase this from any Butcher’s and then cook it. You can obtain this from any large fish such as pike around the rivers to the north. Some of the best rewards in the game are locked behind the challenges, so it makes sense to want to tackle them as they come up. There are four you need to complete Herbalist 9. Note that this challenge tree may result in heavy honor loss. . Fairly easy challenges that really don’t require much guidance, except for the infamous Herbalist 9, see below. There is 10 herbalist challenges in Red Dead Redemption 2 in total and this video tells you all about Challenge 5: Craft Nine Items Using Indian Tobacco as a. Then you MUST complete the mission replay to the end. I'm playing as John Marston and I'm only on Bandit Challenge 1 (forgot to do them as Arthur). Some kinds of meat are easier to procure than others, especially when the animal it comes from only resides in a specific area of the map. William can be found by the player south of Twin Stack Pass in The Heartlands. RDR2 World Map Red Dead Online Map. Rank 6: Kill 5 cougars with your bow, then skin them. Red Dead Redemption 2 Herbalist Challenge #3 Guide - Craft 7 items. Rank 7: Use bait to lure and kill both a herbivore and. 7. Browse game. last updated 10 August 2022 Limber up those green fingers; it's time to take on the Red Dead Redemption 2 Herbalist Challenges Comments The Red Dead Redemption 2. Working on herbalist challenge 4 and wonder what all the mushroom types? I have 4, bay bottle, rams head, chantelle, and parasol. Rank 4: Kill an enemy at least 80 feet away with a thrown tomahawk. This requires you to craft and use 5 Special Miracle TonicsThis one is pain. Herbalist Challenge Reward. Red Dead Redemption 2 has 5 Exotics Quests, consisting of 19 Exotic Locations. It would be great to have the outfit as Arthur as John got the Legend of the. For anyone else who might need the info and is tired or wants to avoid all the riding around trying to find the Berries for the Challenge they are: Raspberries, Blackberries, Evergreen Huckleberries and Wintergreen Berries. Reward. I’ve got Micha stuck on his own up in the mountains by strawberry and that is where I wanna keep him for as long as I can. Red Dead 2 Herbalist Challenge. There is a method where you can get a covered wagon or a covered rickshaw from Saint Denis that will block the sniper bullets once you get into New Austin. 2018. Level 2: Unlocked during the Chapter 2 mission "Pouring Fourth Oil - IV" you will gain the ability to manually mark enemies with the Right Bumper/R1. Sharpshooter. Master Hunter. Step 1: Go near the river you have to cross to get to Blackwater and stand in the middle of it. It is often seen in open green spaces or fields and has a unique yellow flower. After you get him on your horse just ride toward Blackwater a bit, and they're all over on the plains. Our text guide to all the Herbalist Challenges in RDR2 is here: on how to complete all 10 Bandit Challenges in Red Dead Redemption 2Red Dead Redemption 2 Side Missions Walkthrough Playlist:1 - Hold up 5 townsfolk. ” You see, there are only four species of berry in the game, so achieving this rank means. Hold up five townsfolk. Challenge. Horseman - Kill a rabbit on horseback. Season and cook all 11 types of meat. He initiates the Stranger side-mission "To the Ends of the Earth". #RedDeadRedemption2 #RDR2 #WeaponGuide #HowtofindSUBSCRIBE - few types of orchids stop spawning when you have picked 1 short of the list requirement it’s on. org: There are 10 herbalist challenges in Red Dead Redemption 2 in total and this video tells you all about. Woody in RDR2 [video by eli_handle_b. It is possible (albeit extremely difficult) to complete this challenge thread as Arthur Rank 1: Kill five rabbits. First. Bobbie_Lee • Just do the gambler 10 trick. This time I hope the herbalist challenge doesn't bug but now it's about 2 days I'm stuck on gambler challenge 9 and it's the most annoying challenge ever!Possums can be found anywhere at night along most creek banks. There are 9 Challenges Categories, each consisting of 10 challenge tasks: Bandit, Explorer, Gambler, Herbalist, Horseman, Master Hunter, Sharpshooter. Transitory Complete the Herbalist 2 challenge to pick and eat 4 species of berry in Red Dead Redemption 2. A little tip, often when it says "herbs" in the challenge it actually means "plant" - so. It’s letting me make a special snake oil potion and the challenge shows I now need one less crafting👍🏻. Herbalist Tips. This is the best RDR2 tribute. I'm the college prof who taught the first-ever Red Dead Redemption history class. Thanks. These challenges involve Arthur Morgan breaking the law in several different ways, like robbing trains and people, and getting large bounties on your head. Trying to complete the herbalist 9 challenge but I’ve been to so many locations and the Acuna Star Orchid just will not respawn. Amongst Red Dead Redemption 2's story mode are treasure hunts that see players searching for treasure with some basic maps to help them. Sharpshooter- Kill a bird in flight. Herbalist Challenges The Herbalist Challenges involve Arthur Morgan becoming more adept at finding rare plants and herbs, as well as gathering them. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Herbalist Challenge Walkthrough Guide - Herbalist 1: Pick 6 YarrowRed Dead Redemption 2 Challenges Guide Playlist:all challenges except gambler 10 and herbalist 9. Step 5: You can now go to New Austin without. The first Gambler challenge is pretty straightforward, as you must win five hands of poker to clear it. Survivalist - catch a fish. My compendium says I have 33 plants discovered. This was the easiest and quickest way I could find to do the herbalist Challenge 3, the video will show you the location to find sage, theres plenty scattere. . updated Apr 10, 2023 This page addresses how to pick and eat four species of berry found in the world of Red Dead Redemption 2 for Herbalist Challenge 2. My problem is that it won’t let me season all meats. . That was my experience. I started searching my own, and found planty near Valentine, the marked spots are the places to look. i am super active on instagram: Challenges . . So the solution is give the 15 Lady Slipper Orhids (and 15 bird plumes) to the guy, then go and pick up ONE Lady Slipper Orhid. Once you’ve done that, forget about the Herbalist challenges. That should get you through that challenge fairly quickly. Head to the location named Dakota River from the map to grab three plants such as wild mint, common bulrush, and burdock root. . ; Dakota River. Guide on how to complete all 10 Weapons Expert Challenges in Red Dead Redemption 2Red Dead Redemption 2 Side Missions Walkthrough Playlist:complete herbalist challenge #9, I am supposed to find and pick each of the 43 plant species in the game. 0 coins. Me: This is not. I’m doing herbalist 9 and I have picked 42 plants and I don’t know the last one I have to pick. Reddit community for discussing and sharing content relating to Red Dead Redemption 2 & Red Dead Online. I apologize for my late reply, but I thank you for letting me know. Its prerequisite is to complete chapter 1, and rewards are 100 Health XP and $1. RDR2 is BY FAR the best game ever made (of course I'm. These "Challenges" are divided into 9 different categories - Bandit , Explorer , Gambler , Herbalist , Horseman , Master Hunter , Sharpshooter, Survivalist, and Weapons Expert. Some of these challenges, esp herbalist, would really benefit from an expanded view showing. I am stuck on Bandit until chapter 3 when the horse fence opens up, on Master Hunter 10 cuz the Giaguaro will not spawn until I get the legendary animals map from Hosea, and on Sharpshooter 7 cuz I haven't unlocked poison arrows yet. Challenges are a side activity in Red Dead 2. r/reddeadredemption2. You’ll need a recipe that uses sage. Red Dead Redemption 2 has 90 Challenges. All the challenges were completed in chapter 2 and this video. Complete the Herbalist 2 challenge to pick and eat 4 species of berry in Red Dead. Each Version carries over from the previous Version, i. Raspberries can be found in the early areas close to your camp. 'Red Dead Redemption' and the 'Red Dead Redemption' logos are the. 0 coins. Red Dead Redemption 2 - All 43 Plant Locations - Herbalist Challenge 9. These challenges must be done in order,. The herbalist one is a drag though. Herbalist 8 Challenge. Good luck#PS5Share #PS4Share #pcgaming #RDR2. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Herbalist Challenge Walkthrough \ Guide - Herbalist 10: Season and cook all 11 types of meatRed Dead Redemption 2 Challenges Guide Pl. One that has always troubled me was the Herbalist 2 challenge. The Explorer Challenges are all about finding the. Just filter on the plant/herb you're looking for and you can plan your route accordingly. I just got done with the previous one, where I had to win a game of Black Jack after being hit 3 times, 3 times. advertisement As the flora varies. He supplies 5 lists of things, which include bird feathers, alligator eggs, and orchids. Kill and Skin Five Cougars With Your Bow. There is 10 herbalist challenges in Red Dead Redemption 2 in total and this video tells you all about Challenge 2: Pick and Eat Four Species of Berry. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Herbalist Challenge Walkthrough Guide - Herbalist 8: Use Oleander to craft 6 poison weaponsRed Dead Redemption 2 Challenges Guide P. Reward. Red Dead Redemption 2 Bandit Challenges Guide! How to complete all Bandit Challenges in RDR2. Rank 4: Call an animal and get a clean kill 5 times. Red Dead Redemption 2 challenges and rewards. I’m trying to find the random encounter where I get the first map for the High Stakes treasure and I can’t find the guy for the life of me. • 2 yr. In order to get the legend of the east outfit as Arthur you have to finish the herbalist 9 challenge which requires you to collect all 43 plants in the game. 42/43 collected and the last herb didn't spawn at all. Red Dead Redemption 2 Herbalist Challenges guide showing you how to complete the Herbalist challenges in RDR2!Twitch: page:. I did a lot of searching around and found out that the last 6 herbs I need are all in New Austin. Red Dead Redemption 2 has 43 different plants which you can collect. [deleted] • 2 yr. Is it possible to ride to the plants location, pick them up real quick and then die from the bounty hunters, and then repeat 5 times for the 5 plants down there?There is 10 herbalist challenges in Red Dead Redemption 2 in total and this video tells you all about Challenge 9: Pick One of Each Species of Herb. These challenges must be done in order, progress made before they are activated does not count. StillPrompt6739. Requirements: Catch five animals with traps. William One such location is The Heartlands in New Hanover. . ). " Arthur Morgan FO4, "Side Quests, Side Quests never changes. This guide will tell you How To Unlock All Challenges In Red Dead Redemption 2 so you can unlock access to the first tier of each challenge and then advance through completing new and rewarding objectives. Some of the earlier challenges were a bit too difficult IMO. Same as challenges 2 and 4. Horseman Challenges are gameplay challenges which involve performing various actions with your horse in the single-player of Red Dead Redemption 2. Kill 5 flying birds while on a moving train. • 5 yr. Actions towards a challenge aren't counted until that challenge is unlocked. To craft 5 of these you need each Plant 30 times. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Herbalist Challenge Walkthrough Guide - Herbalist 4: Pick 5 mushrooms and feed them to your horseRed Dead Redemption 2 Challenges G. Single-player Challenges are tasks that the player can complete in the single-player mode of Red Dead Redemption 2 in order to earn rewards. Pick five mushrooms and feed them. First, ensure that you have completed the Epilogue 1 mission named ”The Wheel‘. I happen to only have 2. Sharpshooter 2. You can however begin this Challenge right after this mission,. The intent is to prevent you from completing a list before he supplies it. UPDATE: RDR2 Locked Box. . Sitting at 88/90 challenge completion. Please help. You have to walk all the way below D and there is an open grassy region. It never seemed to work right all the time. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Master Hunter Challenge Walkthrough Guide - Master Hunter 5: Skin 3 Black or Grizzly BearsRed Dead Redemption 2 Challenges Guide Pl. During this side mission,. ago. Kill 3 flying birds. Use the links below if you want to jump to a specific section of the challenges list: Red Dead Redemption 2 -. RDR2 Weapons Expert Challenges Guide. Red Dead Redemption 2's Wintergreen Berry is where many players get stuck when completing Herbalist challenge 2. I know most horses are available to tame before blackwater opens up, but the plants are an issue. Gambler 8: 1 hand of 5 cards instead of 3 hands. So I recently got to herbalist 9 and I’m almost finished with %100, I’ve figured the best way to complete this challenge is to go from region to region, one at a time and collect the region specific plants there, look up guides to see what plants spawn in that region, collect them and move on. . In the first encounter, he can be interacted with while picking Indian Tobacco. But to complete some of the achievements its pretty hard especially cuz i am trying it as Arthur. Craft seven items using sage as an ingredient. Rank 5: Catch a fish while boating in the Bayou and while standing on railroad tracks. Searched some Plants for you guys again. I checked the compendium and it said that I found all herbs and orchids. I'm not talking about the "auto challenge mod" that auto completes them for you, I'm looking for a mod that opens them all up from the start, so when I pick a flower at the start of chapter 2, I want it to count for the Herbalist Challenge 9 (where you have to pick all 43 herbs), or when I kill a cougar with an arrow and skin it, let it count for the Master Hunter Challenge 6. 'Red. You’ll also need to complete the Explorer Challenges along with the Herbalist and Survivalist Challenges for the Dead Eye set bonus. The Challenges allow players to become much better at the related. Start herbalist 9, get the herbs (38 out of 43 in total) that are reachable with Arthur. I AM STUCK AT 42/43 PLANTS, I HAVE CHECKED THAT I HAVE DISCOVERED ALL PLANTS AND PICKED ALL OF THEM. You're actually pretty close to. It will also tell you how to. Step 3: Make sure before you reach the exit of the graveyard you are spotted by lawmen. Version 5 has all the features of Versions 1-4 These saves were made using the Ultimate Edition of RDR2 Please note that two users with the Standard Edition of the game have reported issues with Dynamite and the Varmint Rifle. a map specific to this one challenge in all the hundred different things to do in rdr2 do thanks! Looks like. Challenge. Made it to add to my "Herbalist Challenges" article over on Hubpages/Levelskip. ; After that, start the herbalist challenge #9. In Herbalist 9, you need to get all the plants in the game, including the four herbs (desert sage, red sage, black currant, and wild feverfew) from New Austin. Its prerequisite is to complete chapter 1, and rewards are 100 Health XP and $1. e finishing challenge 1 unlocks challenge 2, finishing challenge 2 unlocks challenge 3. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Herbalist Challenge Walkthrough \ Guide - Herbalist 8: Use Oleander to craft 6 poison weaponsRed Dead Redemption 2 Challenges Guide P. Herbalist Challenge: Rank 10: Master. . 3 days time. -possible spoiler-. This was the most satisfying way I could’ve possibly completed this challenge upvotes. See my latest video on it. For the Herbalist 9 challenge, you need to pick all variants of the 43 plants after you get the prompt. Twig + Stone Botanical Medicine. RDR2. From what I hear New Austin is at chapter 6 and I feel like its a little bit too late in the game and would rather. Sharpshooter- Kill a bird in flight. Master Hunter. By: Matt Gibbs Updated: January 9, 2023. The other one has to do with a collectible item I’m still trying to find info about, but it has to be in the regular edition bc I’m currently sitting at 9 tanks and haven’t completed herbalist challenges eitherRed Dead Redemption 2 Spieler können sich mit den Herbalist Challenges des Spiels in der Kräuterkunde versuchen: zehn Reihen von Aufgaben, die sich um das Sammeln und Verwenden der im Spiel gefundenen Pflanzen drehen. In chapter 2, I finished all of the challenges except for Bandit 6 onwards and Gambler 10. This video guide shows all plant locations in Red Dead Redemption 2, useful for Herbalist challenge 9. But I also collected those during the epilogue. Before collecting the herbs, you need to learn the recipe to craft either a “Poison Throwing Knife” or a. The Herbalist challenge asks players to search for 10 different types of plants, one of which is Yarrow. Challenges wise, you technically can't complete herbalist and horsemen as Arthur as they require you to access West Elizabeth and New Austin. I have already completed all ten Explorer, Herbalist, Horseman, Gambler, and Weapons Expert challenges. Can 100% confirm this. xml) After that I picked up all plants and Orchids with John (and got 15 Lady Slipper Orchids) for the exotic mission buut I found out it is not counted towards the challenge until you completing the first exotic mission. Buy the full. Herbalist challenge 6 guide, the locations to 15 different types or kind of herb. Acuna’s Star Orchid Cigar Orchid Clamshell Orchid Dragon’s Mouth Orchid Ghost Orchid Lady of. Weapons Expert. Since my 2nd playthrough I prefer to beat all the challenges as Arthur (I use the buggy method for Herbalist 9). . Getting those last herbs will definitely test your patience. My challenge says I have 19 and that I should use the compendium to track my progress. This challenge should be fixed to only include herbs in the areas available as Arthur, or replace it with another challenge entirely. I did the same, reload the game a couple of times, I went to other towns. Completing this challenge rewards the player with the Herbalist 9 perk, which doubles the yield of herbs when gathering them in the future. As there is no. Master Hunter. Probably best way to complete herbalist 9. . Our text. 69M subscribers 269K views 4 years ago Red. But the count starts over the moment you complete Herbalist 8. Pick a RDR1 character and a RDR2 character you’d want to see interact with each otherHerbalist Challenge 2. Red Dead Redemption 2 story mode features a selection of challenges which reward players with money, experience for the Health, Stamina and Dead Eye cores, and reinforced equipment items which grant permanent bonuses to one of the three main stats once the full set has been acquired. Survivalist. The herbalist challenges were fairly easy to do, except for 5 herbs were found around blackwater and further down in New Austin. I USED GTA SERIES VIDEOS GUIDE TO FIND THEM ALL BUT ITS STILL STUCK AT 42. ” You see, there are only four species of berry in the game, so. . Reward: New weapon belt. Reward: 100 health XP, $15. I must have misunderstood. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Survivalist Challenge Walkthrough Guide - Survivalist 7: Kill 8 small game animals with consecutive shots, using Small Game ArrowsR. e. Survivalist 1. Hi friends! Recently I have been grinding the Herbalist challenges at chapter 2 in order to get the Legend of the East outfit as early as possible, but I am having serious issues finding even a singular Sparrow Egg Orchid. William is a minor character and Stranger in Red Dead Redemption 2. "Pick and eat 4 types of berries" is almost more of an explorer achievement, considering the regions involved. Carolina Parakeet give exotic bird meet. Common Fish in Red Dead Redemption 2. Rank 2: Collect 3 perfect quality rabbit pelts. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Herbalist Challenge Walkthrough \ Guide - Herbalist 5: Craft 9 items using Indian Tobacco as an ingredientRed Dead Redemption 2 Chall. The game is the third entry in the Red Dead series and a prequel to the 2010 game Red Dead Redemption. Any suggestions? Premium Explore Gaming. . Master Hunter - skin a deer. haha. Herbalist 9. Seeing conflicting reports online that this challenge is un-completable (before the epilogue)/is completable. Met William in the heartlands, gave him herbs and everything was good, until I ran after him to say goodbye. Timestamps0:00 - Intro0:11 - Herbalist 1 - 6 Ya. Rob two coaches or return two stolen coaches to a Fence. Bandit challenges can’t be completed in chapter 2 because you need a horse fence for one of them. Browse all gaming. Herbalist 4. $15 and 100 Health XP; Rank 9. There are 10 herbalist challenges in Red Dead Redemption 2 in total and this video tells you all about Challenge 6: Pick 15 Different Species Of Herbs. That was a pain in the ass. It is possible to. Buy the full. Video shows how to complete Red Dead Redemption 2 Herbalist Challenge 9 - pick all 43 herb species and shows Red Dead Redemption all 43 herb species location. My compendium says I have 33 plants discovered. Sharpshooter 1. Also this was the first set I completed. No story spoilers. Enjoy the challenge of completing all the challenges - some are very annoying. r/reddeadredemption2. Herbalist 2: Pick and eat 4 species of berry. KaijunoKami 4 years ago #2. Challenges not completing . Use Eagle Eye to identify any clusters of Red Sage that might have spawned in the area. I thought it would be impossible to keep track of what herbs I needed to collect for Herbalist 9 so I made a spreadsheet with the compendium listed locations of each Herb along with a column to share a more exact location to where I have found them. Step 2: Replay chapter 4 "Angelo Bronte a man of honor" mission. 495 Online. These challenges will test Arthur Morgan to be a perfect shot, and prove your accuracy by shooting moving targets, mastering Dead Eye, and getting long range. *. . Rockstar: I see that you aren't able to complete Herbalist Challenge 9 due to no checklist for the challenge being available in game to tell you what plants are left to be found to complete the challenge. Step 3: Make sure before you reach the exit of the graveyard you are spotted by lawmen. • 2 yr. I have 100% story completion and 92% overall. Make a backup of your save and report issues if you find them. IDK what happened, but I was at 35 of 43 for the longest time. I have used the small carriage that you get from Saint Denis as well as a covered wagon and the Kauffman milk carriage. The game is the third entry in the Red Dead series and a prequel to the 2010 game Red Dead Redemption. Single Player Guides Index. The Herbalist Challenges involve Arthur Morgan becoming more adept at finding rare plants and herbs, as well as gathering them. I’ve found and ate all four berry types and it still says I’m 3/4. Common to West Elizabeth, these berries may be picked, eaten, sold, or used in crafting. ago. Herbalist #9 Walkthrough. Reply. Red Dead Redemption 2 and Red Dead Online feature a crafting and cooking system which allows players to create items such as tonics, special weapons, meals and horse tonics by using a variety of raw materials. Theres no way of knowing in challenges which items you've already collected. 6. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Herbalist Challenge Guide. This will actually take a fair bit of time, because the berries grow in different areas of the map. This will tell you where to get the tonic, the recipe, the materials, and how to make it.